For nonprofit organizations, an audit brings value beyond completing a yearly compliance step. For board members, donors and the public, it can offer evidence of how well the organization protects its resources, honors donor intent, and supports its mission.
Audit red flags should not be viewed only as problems; they are early signals that help leaders ask better questions, strengthen oversight and make the organization resilient in a challenging climate.
Some of the most important red flags result from everyday finance routines. A small nonprofit team might have one person handling several parts of the money process, which can be practical but also makes mistakes harder to catch. The board can help by asking who approves payments, who reviews bank activity, and whether account reviews are completed on time. When delays or gaps appear, the goal is not to place blame, but to understand whether the team needs clearer procedures, stronger documentation, or additional review.
Grant tracking and donor restrictions deserve special attention because they connect directly to trust. Nonprofits need to know which funds are restricted, what those funds may be used for, how spending is matched to the corresponding grant or program and when reports are due. Audit committee questions are useful here because they turn technical tracking into practical oversight: Can management show how restricted gifts were spent, whether grant costs were charged to the correct funding source and whether any reporting deadlines or funder requirements are at risk?
Good governance also means following up on issues instead of letting them repeat. If an audit finding appears year after year, the board should ask what changed (or not) regarding the issue, how any fixes were tested and whether the issue is fully resolved or still in progress. The same thoughtful approach applies when a finance leader leaves, when conflicts of interest need to be disclosed or when staff are encouraged to raise concerns safely. These questions help to set a tone of transparency and accountability without pulling the board into day-to-day management.
Financial resilience is the broader story behind these audit conversations. Boards should understand whether the organization has enough cash to manage normal operations, whether cash flow is steady, whether debt or funder requirements are being met and whether the nonprofit depends too heavily on one donor, grant, program or contract. They can also ask management to explain results by program so they can see whether mission work is aligned with available resources. When audit insights are used this way, they help nonprofit leaders protect funding, strengthen public confidence and plan for sustainable growth.
Schneider Downs will continue to evaluate considerations around audit risks in the nonprofit sector and communicate our insights.
About Schneider Downs Not-for-Profit Services
Our Not-for-Profit industry group is committed to providing exceptional service and expertise to a community of clients who serve our regions tirelessly each day. We provide valuable insight to not-for-profit organizations of all sizes and their boards through our assurance, tax, advisory and technology consulting services and not-for-profit fund accounting software.
To learn more, visit our Not-for-Profit Industry Group page.
