Quick Summary
Total enrollment can obscure where student demand and net tuition revenue are concentrated. Portfolio strategy begins by identifying what truly drives the institution.
Beyond Enrollment Headcount
Higher education leaders spend considerable time discussing enrollment. How many students did we enroll? Which programs are growing? Where are applications declining?
Do you know what is actually driving the majority of your institution?
Applying the 80/20 Lens
The 80/20 principle is used in this series as a strategic lens, not as a claim that every institution’s enrollment or revenue follows an exact 80/20 distribution.
Traditional business thinking often uses some variation of the 80/20 principle: a relatively small number of customers, products or activities may account for a disproportionately large share of results. The percentages are less important than the discipline behind the question.
For colleges and universities, that lens should extend beyond headcount. Which programs account for the majority of enrollment? Which generate the majority of net tuition revenue? Which attract students to the institution or support recruitment and retention across other disciplines? How much institutional capacity is devoted to programs outside those primary drivers?
A Timely Example From Penn State
Pennsylvania State University offers a timely example. Its Academic Portfolio and Program Review evaluated all 403 baccalaureate and associate degree programs. Final recommendations announced in October 2026 identified 47 programs for closure in the coming years. Those programs enroll 784 students, approximately 1.1% of the university’s 68,390 spring 2026 undergraduates. Nine currently have no enrolled students. The recommendations remain subject to established academic governance processes, including Faculty Senate consultation and provost approval.
That does not establish an 80/20 rule for higher education, nor does low enrollment automatically mean a program should disappear. In fact, 24 of the 47 programs would continue through another college within the university.
If a large institution is critically examining programs with limited enrollment, can smaller, more tuition-dependent institutions afford not to conduct the same analysis?
Drivers vs. Deliberate Choices
The objective is not to label everything outside the institution’s primary economic drivers as unnecessary. Some programs define institutional identity, advance mission or embody principles that distinguish the institution. Others support high-demand programs in ways that program-level enrollment alone does not reveal.
Leadership should understand the difference between what drives the institution economically and what it deliberately supports for strategic, academic or mission-related reasons. An 80/20-style analysis is not a prescription for cuts. It is the beginning of a more informed conversation about concentration, resource allocation and institutional priorities.
About This Series
Enrollment pressure, rising costs and changing student demand are reshaping higher education. Institutions that know what drives them, and what they choose to sustain, are in a better position to protect their mission. The Sustainability Equation in Higher Education gives presidents, CFOs and board members a practical framework for making academic portfolio decisions with focus and intention.
Explore the rest of the series for more insights:
- Part 1: Do You Know What Is Driving Your Institution? (you are here)
- Part 2: Mission, History and Principles Still Matter
- Part 3: Financial Sustainability Is Part of the Mission
- Part 4: Stop Asking Only What You Should Cut
- Part 5: What Would You Build If You Were Starting Today?
About Schneider Downs Higher Education Services
The Schneider Downs Higher Education Industry Group is a dedicated team of experienced professionals specializing in serving institutions from high schools to universities. Our experience in audit and assurance, tax advisory, technology and data and more allow our professionals to stay ahead of the latest trends, developments and challenges within the education sector and provide timely and practical solutions to our clients.
For more information, contact the Higher Education team.